Post Digital Detox Reflection

After reading How to Break Up With Your Phone by Catherine Price, I have just completed the one-month challenge to break up with my phone. The first part of the book focuses on convincing readers that their phones may be doing more harm than good, covering the many truths and hidden impacts behind our little screens. Following this, the book guides readers through a month-long process to prepare for the “breakup.” The first three weeks consist of exercises designed to slowly create separation, and the final week ends with a 24-hour digital detox. Here is my analysis of how it went and what I thought.

Digital Detox Final Analysis

December 4, 2025

Now that I have completed the digital detox, it is really interesting to look back on my initial plans and the rules and guidelines I had set for myself. In many ways, I am happy that I prepared the way I did, but I also surprised myself by needing fewer “replacement” activities than I expected. I found that I was able to fill my time in more authentic, natural ways that didn’t always connect directly to the detox or my original preparation. Initially, I believed Thanksgiving would be the worst day to attempt the detox. I was thinking about all of the unstructured time early in the day, and also how I would want to go for a long run or walk which usually coincides with my phone and listening to a podcast or music. I also anticipated that I would want to stay in touch with family members and friends, especially because our Thanksgiving this year was just my immediate family and a few close friends. But as the break went on, I realized that Thanksgiving might actually be the best time to try it. I started thinking about how Thanksgiving is already a day focused on slowing down, staying present, and appreciating the people and things around you, all of which are key themes we’ve discussed in this class regarding phone use and time spent in nature. 

Looking back at my preparation, I can see why certain choices helped set me up for success. Before the detox, I picked out a book I was excited to read and set aside a journal so I would have meaningful screen-free activities ready throughout the day. I also considered practical details, like bringing a wallet in case I went anywhere, since I usually rely on digital payments. In addition, I planned several activities, like walking, baking, and spending time with family, that could help fill the time in a positive way. However, while all of these strategies were helpful and are things I would use on other occasions, I found that they were somewhat unnecessary on Thanksgiving. I never had to leave the house to buy anything, I was surrounded by people the entire day, and I stayed naturally engaged without needing to force replacement activities. Despite my initial hesitation, Thanksgiving turned out to be the perfect setting to complete this challenge. Before diving into specifics, my day was perfect. I woke up naturally, went for a long run at the beach, my favorite place, then came home, helped cook, showered, and headed over to our friends’ house where we finished the day.

Spending the entire day with my family and friends during the detox aligned closely with my philosophy of technology use. One of my core values is connection, and I usually think of technology as a tool that can support and enhance it. On Thanksgiving, I realized that my phone was not necessary for connection because I was surrounded by people who know me best and who I already share strong connections with. Being fully present allowed me to notice details I might normally miss, the conversations, the laughter, the small interactions during the games we played, and it made me appreciate how meaningful and memorable these moments were. This experience helped me see that technology often functions as a substitute for real-life connection, and that being without it can actually deepen my awareness and enjoyment of relationships and experiences. At the same time, I don’t view technology as inherently negative. In my everyday life, my phone adds value by helping me stay in touch with people, make plans, and capture memorable experiences. But on Thanksgiving, the connection I wanted was right in front of me, so I wasn’t looking elsewhere or relying on my phone for it. I also recognized that connection is not about constant stimulation or checking texts, it is about being attentive, engaged, and present. This was a new perspective for me, and one I hope to carry forward, reminding me that technology should enhance, and not replace, human relationships and connections.

One of the decisions I made for the day was that I was allowed to keep football, and in my opinion, that decision fits completely within my philosophy of balanced technology use. Football is, and has always been, something that I genuinely enjoy, and it also creates another opportunity for connection since it is something my family does together and all enjoy. Watching the football games on Thanksgiving has always been something I look forward to. With my philosophy, keeping the TV on in the background was not a violation of the digital detox, rather it was a decision that supported my life and the balance that I value. I believe this reflects my idea that technology, when used intentionally, can enhance well-being and add to meaningful experiences rather than take away from them. This choice also highlights how my experience challenges the patterns that Stephanie J. Vialle describes in Better Than Scrolling: Digital Detox in the Search for the Ideal Self. Vialle explains that people often feel an incongruence between their ideal self, disciplined, present, and self controlled, and their actual self, which they view as distracted, stressed, or enslaved to their devices. Her framework suggests that technology is the barrier that creates this gap. However, watching football did not make me feel that disconnect or any sense of failure, stress, or lack of discipline. Instead, it aligned with my values of connection, tradition, and intentional technology use, rather than threatening the version of myself I strive to be.​​  

Looking back on the day, watching football did not pull me away from anything, it was a part of it. Reflecting on this, I realized that my phone is not something that keeps me from being my best self, and I take pride in the way I try to balance my phone use. My experience challenges Vialle by showing that technology does not always create this tension, rather, it can support the ideal self when used intentionally. 

Another important layer of my digital detox that I had not fully considered beforehand was the fact that it took place during a holiday break. One of the most memorable aspects of my Thanksgiving detox was how present I felt throughout the day. I was not thinking about texts, homework, or other responsibilities. On the contrary, it felt natural and effortless to stay engaged with the people and activities around me. One factor that made this possible and enhanced my experience was the absence of the distractions that are typically present in my everyday life. There was no schoolwork to stress over, no friends creating drama, and no other social distractions that inherently occur at school. The day was organically structured around spending time with loved ones and enjoying their company, creating an environment in which the detox was highly supported and enjoyable. This aligns with a key idea Maria Popova addresses in Leisure, the Basis of Culture. In the article, leisure is presented as something always in opposition to work and productivity. In a culture that promotes a productivity fetishism, the line between work and leisure is blurred, preventing individuals from engaging with and enjoying free time in ways that are not dominated by obligations, stress, or anxiety about productivity. I realize that on a normal day, I usually fall victim to this phenomenon. Thanksgiving was different. Leisure was built into the day. There was a break from school, work, and external pressures, and everyone was able to be present and experience the stillness and engagement that Popova describes. This raises questions about whether I could have experienced this as fully or easily at another time. Can leisure truly exist alongside work? There is so much discussion about how technology disrupts things, but this experience made me realize that it might also be the constant grind and productivity culture that prevents individuals, including myself, from experiencing the calm and engagement I felt on Thanksgiving.

I not only noticed various things in myself during the phone detox, but this experience also helped me notice patterns in other people regarding digital use. It was interesting to see how people engaged with their phones throughout the day, especially from my unique perspective. Stepping back from my phone gave me a clearer way to see how digital patterns operate in everyday life. In the book, How to Break Up With Your Phone, Catherine Price has her readers identify their own habits and emotions tied to their phones, and once I completed that exercise, I became much more aware of similar behaviors in others. This awareness didn’t occur because Catherine Price told me to study others, rather it was because understanding my own patterns made me naturally more sensitive to what these patterns look like from the outside.

As I watched the people around me, I started to see some of the habits that Price describes when she explains the various tactics technology uses to engage, capture, and retain its users. I noticed how quickly my mom would take out her phone for pictures, and how often my dad would check scores of other games, and how eager people were to be on social media to see what others were doing. These behaviors matched the small, repeated actions that Price asks her readers to identify in themselves. It made me feel validated in a way to know that these are universal, and not just things I found in myself. Further, these observations validated everything Price writes about. A key theme in Part One was how our attention spans become disrupted by our phones and their constant interruptions, and I noticed that I was able to remain more engaged and focused than others simply because my phone was not present. I watched people shift back and forth between their phones and conversations, perfectly illustrating the dynamic Price describes. The detox, along with all the information Price shared, allowed me to see this play out in real time, and it was truly a breakthrough moment for me. This clarity is powerful, and I believe it could make a meaningful difference if others experienced it as well.

Works Cited

Popova, M. (2017, March 4). Leisure, the basis of culture: An obscure German philosopher’s timely 1948 manifesto for reclaiming our human dignity in a culture of workaholism. The Marginalian. https://www.themarginalian.org/2015/08/10/leisure-the-basis-of-culture-josef-pieper/ 

Price, C. (2025). How to break up with your phone. Ten Speed Press. 

Vialle, S. J., Machin, T., & Abel, S. (2024). Better than scrolling: Digital Detox in the search for the ideal self. Psychology of Popular Media, 13(4), 687–695. https://doi.org/10.1037/ppm0000496